Serial extractions are a preventive orthodontic approach typically used during the mixed dentition phase, usually between ages 6 and 12, to manage severe dental crowding.
📌 Recommended Article :
Dental Article 🔽 Indications and Contraindications of Serial Extractions in Pediatric Dentistry: Updated Clinical Guide ... This article reviews the clinical importance, key indications and contraindications, and current recommendations based on recent scientific evidence.While this method has proven effective in many clinical cases, it remains controversial among dental professionals due to concerns about facial esthetics, timing, and the growing availability of less invasive alternatives. This article outlines the key controversies surrounding serial extractions and discusses when — and if — they’re still justified in modern orthodontic care.
Advertisement
✅ What Are Serial Extractions?
Serial extractions involve the planned, staged removal of certain baby teeth and permanent teeth to guide the proper eruption and alignment of the remaining teeth. This is typically indicated in children with a tooth-size/arch-length discrepancy, where the jaws are too small to accommodate all the permanent teeth.
📌 Recommended Article :
Video🔽 What are impacted canines? - Treatment ... Impacted canines is a common anomaly, and is especially seen in the maxilla. The cause of the retention of the canine should be evaluated clinically and radiographically.✅ Main Controversies
1. Facial Esthetics and Profile Changes
One of the most debated issues is the potential flattening of the facial profile after removing premolars, especially in cases where excessive space closure causes a loss of lip support.
| A study by Boley et al. (2002) showed that serial extractions can lead to noticeable changes in the facial profile, particularly in patients with borderline crowding.
2. Uncertainty About the Best Timing
There is no universally accepted timeline for initiating serial extractions. While some clinicians prefer early intervention around ages 8–9, others suggest waiting until more is known about eruption patterns and skeletal growth to avoid premature or unnecessary extractions.
3. Risk of Arch Collapse or Uncontrolled Space Loss
If not carefully monitored, serial extractions may lead to undesirable tooth movements, collapse of the dental arch, or deep bites — especially if orthodontic appliances are not used to control space closure.
4. Modern Alternatives to Extraction
Advancements in orthodontic techniques, such as palatal expanders, distalizing appliances, and clear aligners, have made it possible to treat moderate to severe crowding without removing teeth. This challenges the traditional view that extraction is the only solution in such cases.
5. Parental Concerns and Ethical Dilemmas
Parents may feel uncomfortable with the idea of extracting seemingly healthy teeth from their children, raising ethical concerns and resistance to treatment unless the goals and benefits are clearly explained.
📌 Recommended Article :
Dental Article🔽 How Long Should Orthodontic Treatment Last? Procedures, Duration, and Scientific Justification ... The success of reimplantation depends on many factors among which are the time lapse before the tooth is reimplanted in the socket and the storage medium of the avulsed tooth.💬 Discussion
While serial extractions were once a gold standard in managing crowding, modern orthodontics has shifted toward more conservative, individualized treatment planning. Not every case of crowding requires tooth removal — especially in light of improved diagnostic tools and non-extraction techniques.
It is essential for clinicians to carefully evaluate:
° The degree of crowding.
° The patient’s growth pattern and facial type.
° Long-term esthetic and functional outcomes.
Serial extractions remain useful in select cases, but overuse or poor planning can lead to avoidable complications.
💡 Conclusion
Serial extractions still have a place in interceptive orthodontics, but their use should be judicious and case-specific. Modern orthodontic philosophy emphasizes minimally invasive approaches, patient-centered care, and long-term esthetic and functional balance.
Ultimately, the controversy lies not in whether serial extractions work — but in when, how, and for whom they are truly necessary.
📌 Recommended Article :
PDF/Video 🔽 Space Maintainer in Pediatric Dentistry: How do they work? Benefits and indications ... We share a complete study and review on the importance, indications, types and effectiveness of space maintainers in pediatric dentistry.📚 References
✔ Boley, J. C., Markin, S., & Sachdeva, R. (2002). Long-term stability of Class I premolar extraction treatment. The Angle Orthodontist, 72(5), 432–437. https://doi.org/10.1043/0003-3219(2002)072<0432:lsocip>2.0.CO;2
✔ Proffit, W. R., Fields, H. W., & Sarver, D. M. (2018). Contemporary Orthodontics (6th ed.). Elsevier.
✔ Rinchuse, D. J., & Rinchuse, D. J. (2014). Evidence-based decision making in orthodontics. Journal of the American Dental Association, 145(3), 239–243. https://doi.org/10.14219/jada.2013.28
📌 More Recommended Items
► Tooth extractions in orthodontics? - Why Do Orthodontists Extract Teeth?
► Early Treatment of Anterior Crossbite with Eruption Guidance Appliance: A Case Report
► Orthodontics: What is Interproximal Reduction (IPR)
